The move to introduce midweek replays for FA Cup ties has sparked widespread backlash from EFL and non-league clubs, who claim they were not adequately consulted. The response has been so vehement that there are talks of mass protests and potential boycotts of the competition directed towards the FA and Premier League. In response to the overwhelmingly negative reaction, the FA has issued a fresh statement, acknowledging that they “understand” the concerns of clubs and fans.
They have pledged to monitor the situation closely as the new calendar unfolds to ensure that EFL and National League clubs do not suffer as a result of the changes. In light of the criticism, former Newcastle and England footballer Alan Shearer has criticized the FA for their handling of the decision, suggesting that changes such as scrapping extra time and ensuring equal financial distribution among clubs could be more reasonable approaches. He also highlighted the challenges posed by the expansion of UEFA dates from six to ten weeks.
The sentiments expressed by various stakeholders underscore the controversial nature of the FA Cup changes and the need for a more inclusive and thoughtful approach in the decision-making process.
